This is a highly imaginative recording. "Period" sound effects and "overheard" dialog knit together the various songs and pieces from the 1890s to early 20th century US. The selection of material is excellent, including a version of "Take Me Out tot he Ball Game" in Yiddish. Ethnic New York is also represented by "Has Anybody Here Seen Kelly," "Cohen Owes Me Ninety Seven Dollars," and Bert Williams famous "Nobody." Most of the vocalists are outstanding, and the instrumental accompaniments sound very authentic and spirited.. The little photo album that accompanies the CD provides some of the atmosphere of turn-of-the-century New York. I do have a couple of criticisms. Some of the male vocalists are half lost in the sound of the band. Also, while all of the artists are accounted for, simply listing them on the last page make it impossible to tell who is singing or playing what. Nevertheless, whether you are new to the music of early Tin Pan Alley or a collector of this type of music, this is a great album to own